15 and 16? — A Double Birthday of Lawrence of Arabia

Last Updated 06 JAN. 2017 [ver.1.15]
by YAGITANI Ryoko, Japan

BOTTOM




[Iwanami World Biographical Dictionary, 2013 ]
from Iwanami World Biographical Dictionary, Two Volumes, 2013, 3610pp.
Have you ever looked up T. E. Lawrence (TEL) on a biographical dictionary or an encyclopedia?

When a new biographical dictionary was published in December 2013 in Japan, I looked up an article of TEL and found very strange dates on it:

Lawrence, Thomas Edward 1888.8.15 - 1935.5.13

“Not on 13th TEL died, the day of his fatal crash, but 19th. An evident mistake!”
So I said to myself, then, sunk into thought about the date of TEL was born.
The date has not always tallied — some books say it was 15th, some 16th.
Let's arrange information on this matter.

† Please note that some letters are emphasized with blue color by this article's author.
Fifteenth August [15.8.1888] — His official birthday

CERTIFIED COPY OF AN ENTRY OF BIRTH
Given at the General Register Office

[Birth Certificate]

Registration district: FESTINIOG
1888 Birth in the Sub-district of Tremadoc in the Counties of Merioneth & Carnarvon

His record was on Column No. 31.


Richard Aldington also researched the T. E. Lawrence's birth certificate. See Lawrence of Arabia: a Biographical Enquiry, London: Collins, 1955, p.25

Desmond Stewart noted that:
*On his matriculation entry he had given 15 August, Napoleon's birthday. The same date survives on the copy of the Kennington bust in Jesus Chapel. [ T. E. Lawrence, a New Biography, London: Hamish Hamilton, 1977 (Harper & Row, 1977 ed. p.24; Granada Publishing, 1979 ed., p,24)]



There are two mentions of birthday in Seven Pillars of Wisdom, at CHAPTER CIII.
Accordingly I spent hours apart by myself, taking stock of where I stood, mentally, on this my thirtieth birthday. It came to me queerly how, four years ago, I had meant to be a general and knighted, when thirty. [Penguin ed., p.579]

On this birthday in Bair, to satisfy my sense of sincerity, I began to dissect my beliefs and motives, groping about in my own pitchy darkness.[Penguin ed., p.580]

There is Appendix II, “table of our movements or position-at-night is from my skeleton diary” at the end of the book. According to that, he was at Bair on 15th, and El Hadi on 17th. That means on both days of 15 and 16, he was at Bair.

John Mack wrote:
Lawrence wrote in Seven Pillars of Wisdom that as he approached his thirtieth birthday (August 15, 1918) he looked back upon medieval-Napoleonic fantasied of glory and achievement that he had previously entertained:... [Mack, p.193]



There is no mention of the date of TEL's birth in the 1927 biography Lawrence and the Arabs (London: Jonathan Cape). Robert Graves wrote only “He was born at Tremadoc in North Wales in August 1888” [p.12].


Canon E. F. Hall, then 98 years old, was interviewed by Malcolm Brown for the 1986 BBC documentary, and his memory of TEL are on A Touch of Genius: The Life of T. E. Lawrence, 1988.
[Canon E. F. Hall, 1986]
Canon Hall talked about “Napoleon's birthday.” [from YouTube: T E Lawrence and Arabia. BBC documentary pt 1 of 7]
Birth Certificate
First of all, I'm bringing forward evidence for the fifteenth day — his birth certificate. I order the document from UK via Internet on February 2014 (it cost £25!). Here the transcription of TEL's birth certificate.

When and
where born
Name, if anySexName and surname
of father
Name, surname and
maiden surname
of mother
Fifteenth
August
1888

Gorphwysfa
Tremadoc
Carnarvon
Wales
Thomas
Edward
BoyThomas
Lawrence
Sarah
Larwence
formerly
Maden
Occupation of
father
Signature, description and
residence of informant
When
registered
Signature of
registar
Name entered
after
registration
GentlemanThomas Lawrence
Father
Gorphwysfa
Tremadoc
Twernty
Seventh
August
1888
Richard
Parry
Registrar
/


Who's Who, Encyclopedia Britannica and DNB
TEL in Who was Who It was 1920, when TEL firstly appeared on Who's Who. After the edition of 1923 his birth date mentioned, and TEL was apparently responsible for the contents. It reads that:
LAWRENCE, Thomas Edward, Research Fellow of All Souls College, Oxford, 1919; b. Wales, 15 Aug. 1888. Educ.: Oxford High School, Jesus College, Oxford; Magdalen College, Oxford (Senior Demy. B.A.1911);...[1923 ed., p.1604]
TEL legally changed his surname to Shaw in 1927. After the 1928 edition of Who's Who, his was in the directory as Thomas Edward Shaw. See the image shown to the left, a photocopy of Who was Who 1929-1940.

Next, let us see an encyclopedia. According to the Philip O'Brien's bibliography, the very first encyclopedia which had TEL's entry was the 13th edition of Encyclopaedia Britannica, pulished in 1926. Unfortunately, I could not find the 13th edion, but the 14th edition published in 1929, with a TEL article written by D. G. H. [D. G. Hogarth] and a contributor X. Because Hogarth died on 6 November 1927, I consider that Mr X amend the article written by Hogarth for the 13th edition. See the following image. Again, Aug. 15 1888 is his birth date.
TEL in Britannica 1929

In Dictionary of National Biography 1931-1940, published in 1949, Sir Ronald Storrs (1881-1955) wrote:
Lawrence, Thomas Edward 1888-1935, known as ‘Lawrence of Arabia’ was born at Tremadoc, North Wales, 15 August 1888, the second in a family of five sons.
Napoleon's Birthday
Fifteenth of August is the birthday of Napoleon Bonaparte. B. H. Liddell Hart mentioned that:
Lawrence, now on the threshold of his first Arabia campaign, was exactly two years older than Napoleon Bonaparte in his first Italian campaign - for both were born on the same day of the year, August 15th. [‘T. E. Lawrence’ In Arabia and After, London: Jonathan Cape, 1934, pp.120-21]

Liddell Hart wrote this biography with the help of TEL, so that his birthdate information must have been offered from TEL himself.
Another Napoleon reference was found on a memory of a school friend, Ven. Edgar Francis Hall (1888-1987). He wrote that:
E. F. Hall in Who was Who My earliest recollection of Lawrence is that of sitting by his side in the Lower Fouth at school, establishing to my satisfaction that I was exactly one day his senior in age, to be met by the retort that this was unfortunate, since it prevented me from being born, as he was, on Napoleon's birthday. Thus early was the future taking shape. [Friends, p.44]
This means that E. F. Hall must have been born on 14 August, the day before Napoleon's birthday. Yes, Who was Who 1981-1990 gives evidence of that (see the image above). E. F. Hall's memory suggests that TEL enjoyed himself having the same birthday as Napoleon in his school days.

In the armed forces
There is another evidence. TEL himself wrote about his fortieth birthday to Charlotte Shaw on 15 August 1928, when he worked in the RAF base in Miranshah, now Afghanistan:
Lots of people tell me I am forty, and should be deciding to do somehing with my life. Help! It is comfortable, I think, on the whole, to be getting older... [Letters III, p.151]
This means that his coworkers in Miranshah considered his birthday was 15th.
Please allow me to add my memory here. When ‘Lawrence of Arabia, The Life, The Legend ’ exhibition was held in the Imperial War Museum, London in 2005-2006, his Tank Corps Enlistment Certificate was exhibited. I remember that the date of his birth was filled out on it as 15 August 1888, the same date as on the birth certificate.

From all of the above evidences, it follows that birth date of TEL was 15 August 1888, beyond any doubt ... for now.

Sixteenth August [16.8.1888] — His real birthday

Photo shown to the left, taken by YAGITANI Ryoko in 1983.

Images of TEL's grave in the Web

Editors of correspondence made notes on TEL's birthday.
By David Garnett:
August 16 1906 [His eighteenth birthday] [DG, p.45]
By Bob Lawrence, his elder brother:
16 August 1908 {His tweentieth birthday} [HL, p.73].
Leading biographers wrote:
1955: Richard Aldington
...was born in “the small hours” of the 16th August, 1888. He was registered as born on the 15th by his father,... [Aldington, p.25]
1969: Knightley & Simpson
...was born in the early hours of 16 August 1888... [Lives, p.9]
1976: John Mack
...on August 16, 1888. [Mack, p.5]
1977: Desmont Stewart
... was born in the early hours of 16 August 1888. [Stewart, p.6]
1988: Malcolm Brown
Born 1888, 16 August,... [MB, p.xvii]
1989: Jeremy Wilson (Authorized biographer)
...was born in the early hours of 16th August 1888... [Wilson, p.20] [his web site]
1990: Lawrence James
...was born on 16 August 1888... [The Golden Warrior, p.3]
2010: Michael Korda
...on August 16, 1888; [Hero, p.127]


TEL said he had never seen his birth certificate in 1927, I wonder if it is true. He may have had an opportunity to submit that. Because of his birth at Tremadoc, he won a Welsh scholarship, a Meyricke Exhibition from Jesus College, Oxford. I suspect that the college must have required a paper to prove the place he was born. He submitted his birth certificate, though, didn't read that?
His Mother's Statement
T. E. Lawrence's gravestone [1983] Now let's examine the evidence of the sixteenth day.
If you visit the grave of T. E. Lawrence in Moreton, Dorset, you'll see the gravestone made by Eric Kennington, settled after summer of 1936. It reads

BORN 16 AUGUST 1888
DIED 19 MAY 1935


This gravestone was ordered by TEL's mother and elder brother Robert. Mother should be a very reliable witness — his mother, Sarah Lawrence wrote that:
My second son, Thomas Edward was born at Tremadoc, Carnarvonshire, in the early hours of August 16th, 1888. [Friends, p.25]
Lawrence's Statement
His mother said it was 16th. The son, TEL knew that? I've tried to find another evidence — Yes, he knew. There were some tips in books of his correspondence.
Letter to home on Friday morning {August 17th}, 1906 from Dinard, he wrote:
Was it note extraordinary that my tour this year ended on the 16th of August, my birthday, just as my tour last summer fo Norfolk did? [HL, p.20]

T. E. Lawrence to Charlotte Shaw on 17 August 1924, Cloulds Hill, Moreton
Yesterday was an occation, to, of its sort. I celebrated a birthday. By my pay-book (full of queer statements about me) it was my twentieth. By may attestation form it was my thietieth. By truth it must have been my thirty-sixth. The day justified itself splendidly. [Letters I, p.90]
The most important letter I believe, dated 16 June 1927, was publised in 1988, in Letters of T. E. Lawrence, edited by Malcolm Brown.

To The Hon Edward Eliot [*1]
16. VI. 27

Drigh Road Karach India
Yes, I want to change my name formally. Will you try and do it as quietly and inexpensively as it can be done? I'd better be
Thomas Edward Shaw
in future. Of Pole Hill, Chingford, Essex, if they require an address.
    I'm in some doubt as to my previous name, for I've never seen my birth certificate. I fancy I was registred as born on August 15, 1888 (which was not the real date, however!)[*2] at Tremadoc, in Carnarvon County, N. Wales. My father and mother, who were not married: — or rather he was, but not to her — called themselves Lawrence, at least from 1892 onwards. I do not know whether they did so when I was born or not.[*3] ... [The rest is omitted]

Notes by the editor [Malcolm Brown]
*1 Lawrence's solicitor and a trustee of the Revolt in the Desert fund.
*2 He was actually born in the early hours of 16 August.
*3 Both parents are named Lawrence in T.E.'s birth certificate. [MB, p.333]


T. E. Lawrence wrote that August 15 was NOT the real date, and 16th was his birthday. His mother confirmed that.

Lawrence's Baptism record in 1904
On 5 January 2017, I found the baptism record of T. E. Lawrence, at page 95 of the parish register of St. Aldates Church, Oxford. He was baptized by the rector, Rev. Alfred Christopher on 26 March 1904 at the age of fifteen. The birth date was added as “born August 16 1888”. This is the most reliable record of his birthday.
TEL in Who was Who
Conclusion

TEL was checked his birth certificate when he tried to enlist the RAF in 1922. Stanley Weintraub wrote:
“Ross” had no papers of identity, and was told that regulations required a birth certificate, attestation to his sound moral character, and a reference from his past employer. He gave a date of birth and offered to get the other credentials. When Johns [Chief Recruiting Officer] checked with the birth records office in Somerset House he descoverd, not to his surprise, that there was no birth certificate. [Private Shaw and Public Shaw: a Dual Portrait of Lawrence of Arabia and G. B. S., New York: George Braziller, 1963, p.9]
Also see Chapter 12, “Into the Ranks”, in Secret Lives of Lawrence of Arabia by Phillip Knightley & Colin Simpson, Thomas Nelson, 1969.
All things considered, he had two of birthdays:

    15 August 1888 — his official birthday, registred incorrectly by his father; the day for filling out public papers, or for claiming a connection with Napoleon.
    16 August 1888 — his real birthday, confirmed by his mother, his gravestone and the parish register; the day for celebrating.

Now the latter date is accepted as the date of his birth, as it is written in A Touch of Genius: The Life of T. E. Lawrence by Malcolm Brown & Julia Cave:
The accepted date of Lawrence's birth is 16 August — he was apparently born in the early hours of that day — but his birth certificate distinctly assigns it to the 15th, a date which Lawrence himself was proud to claim, it being the birthday of Napoleon. [GENIUS, p.4]
Since the birth certificate is often used as a proof of one's identity, British people (just as it is in Japan) have to use the same date as on them, when the date of birth is needed on public documents. TEL used different days according to the circumstances, and could manage it successfully. I suggest that this could affect his character, made him rather resourceful, capable of dealing with difficult situations.


The Dates on Encyclopedia Articles

Though there are so many mistakes in encyclopedias and dictionaries in Japanese , I do not touth about them here. (In Japanese page, I will.)

I'd like to mention one thing, about the Japanese version of Encyclopedia Britannica, first published in 1974. It has an article of TEL with the birth date of 1888.08.15/6, thanks to Professor NAKANO Yoshio, the contributor for the Macropaedia volume.

NAKANO, a well known biographer of TEL in Japan, did not translate the article in the English version, but wrote a very fulfilling one for Japanese readers. I believe that his article is one of the best TEL articles in encyclopedias in the world.



It is strange why even Stanley Weintraub wrote it was 15th. I must say that Robert Graves did a good job for Collier's Encyclopedia in 1969.


No more paper Britannica!
The Encyclopedia Britannica has announced that after 244 years, dozens of editions and more than 7m sets sold, no new editions will be put to paper. The 32 volumes of the 2010 installment, it turns out, were the last. [The Guardian, 13 March 2012]

It means that whoever ask any of the paper edition of Britannica about TEL's birthday, shall only get answer of 15th August.

The Oxford DNB
The 60 volume print edition of the Oxford DNB is still available. See this page.

I wonder which contributor wrote the article of TEL in the latest print edtion of the Oxford DNB. Ronald Storrs, or Lawrence James? Can anyone check this?
Yes, he was actually born on 16th of August.
However, this may be special information for T. E. Lawrence enthusiasts who read TEL's letters and biographies. People who have no special interest in TEL, may look up him on a biographical dictionary or an encyclopedia? We have arleady checked some of reference books with the 15th date. What books or when did they accept the 16th day?

I have tried everything possible to look TEL up in encyclopedias in English, published after 1926, here in Japan. Fortunately, some public libraries in Saitama and Tokyo keep out-of date encyclopedias in their bookshelves. Thanks to those libraries!

The following is a list of books I reached. I inform you that some of years books published are based on Philip O'Brien's bibliography.

T. E. Lawrence at Encyclopedias (and DNB) in English
Year published Book title Date and Place of TEL's Birth Contributor(s)
1926 [13th Ed.] Encyclopaedia Britannica, Vol.13 this copy is unfound in public libraries in Japan. WANTED! [D. G. Hogarth]
1929 [14th Ed. A] Encyclopaedia Britannica, Vol.13 born in Wales on Aug. 15, 1888 D. G. H.; X.
1945 Compton's Pictured Encyclopedia, Vol.8 born Aug. 15, 1888, in North Wales.
1949 Dictionary of National Biography 1931-1940 born at Tremadoc, North Wales, 15 August 1888 Ronald Storrs
1950 The Encyclopedia Americana, Vol.17 b. Portmadoc, Caernarvonshire, Wales, 15 Aug. 1888
1950 Chambers's Encyclopedia, Vol.8 Born on 15 August at Tremadoc, Carnarvonshire J. E. E.
1958 The American Peoples Encyclopedia, Vol.12 1888
born in Portmadoc, Wales.
N. S.
1959 Collier's Encyclopedia, Vol.12 born at Portmadoc, Caenarvonshire, Wales, on Aug. 15, 1888. R. T.
1962 /
1968
The Encyclopedia Americana, Vol.17 b. Tremadoc, Caernarvonshire, Wales, Aug. 15, 1888.
1965 Britannica Junior Encyclopaedia for Boys and Girls, Vol.9 1888
born in Wales.
1969 Collier's Encyclopedia, Vol.14 born at Tremadoc, North Wales, on Aug. 16, 1888. Robert Graves
1965 [14th Ed. C] Encyclopaedia Britannica, Vol.13 born in Wales on Aug. 15, 1888, at Tremadoc, Caernarvonshire. J. B. GL. [John Bagot Glubb, aka Glubb Pasha]
1970 Compton's Encyclopedia, Vol.13 born Aug. 15, 1888, in Portmadoc, Wales.
1974-1984
[15th Ed. A]
The New Encyclopaedia Britannica: Macropaedia, Vol.6 (b. Aug. 15, 1888, Tremadoc, Caernarvonshire — d. May 19, 1935, Clouds Hill, Dorset)
Micropaedia, Vol.10 born in Wales (at Tremadoc, Caernarvonshire) on August 15, 1888. S. We. [Stanley Weintraub]
1985-2010 [15th Ed. B] Encyclopaedia Britannica, Vol.15 (b. Aug. 15, 1888, Tremadoc, Caernarvonshire, Wales d. May 19, 1935, Clouds Hill, Dorset, Eng.)
S. We. / Ed.
1996 The Encyclopedia Americana, Vol.17 born in Tremadoc, North Wales, on Aug. 15, 1888. N. H. Gibbs [Norman Henry Gibbs]
2000 The World Book Encyclodedia, Vol.12 1888
born in Tremadoc, Wales.
Ian F. E. Beckett
2004 / 2011 Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Online Edition born on 16 August 1888 at Woodlands, Tremadoc, Caernarvonshire. [Click here] Lawrence James
Last Updated 10-9-2013 Encyclopaedia Britannica Online [HOME] (born August 16, 1888, Tremadoc, Caernarvonshire, Wales—died May 19, 1935, Clouds Hill, Dorset, England) [Click here] Stanley Weintraub


To my surprise, no Encyclopaedia of paper edition, except the 1969 Collier's Encyclopedia told us it was 16th August when TEL was born. Due to this, if you rely such reference books to confirm T. E. Lawrence's birthday, there is a high probability that you'll be given the date of 15th. On the other hand, Online edition of the Oxford DNB and Britannica amended the date.

There is still room for addition in this list. If you find any reference book to add here, please let me know.


*HOME PAGE
This page's URL: http://yagitani.na.coocan.jp/en/tpc_en15.htm